Safety first: Active fire, gas smell, or water near electrical panels? Call 911 first.
Call Jack · (646) 535-8762

Insurance claim guide

How to handle a water or fire damage insurance claim in New York

Updated · Restore Now NYC

Quick answer: The right order after water or fire damage in New York: make the property safe and call a restoration company for emergency mitigation and documentation, notify your insurer the same day, talk to a licensed public adjuster before the insurer's inspection or any recorded statement, return any sworn proof of loss within 60 days of the insurer's written request, and don't accept a settlement until the full damage — including hidden moisture and smoke damage — has been measured.

Need help now? Call Jack at (646) 535-8762

Our crew serves Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island and Westchester.

Hour 0–24: stop the damage and start the record

Your policy expects you to protect the property from further damage, and most homeowners and commercial policies say so in a section usually titled "Duties After Loss." That means stopping the water, starting the drying, and boarding up or tarping openings — right away, not after the adjuster visits.

A restoration company does more than dry and clean. It photographs the damage, takes moisture readings inside walls and floors, and keeps drying logs. That record is often the strongest evidence in your claim, because it shows exactly what was damaged and that you acted quickly.

Same day: notify your insurer — briefly

Report the loss to your insurer or agent promptly. Late notice is one of the easiest ways for a claim to get into trouble. Keep the first call short and factual: what happened, when, and where. Get a claim number and write down who you spoke with.

You don't need to estimate the damage, guess at the cause, or give a recorded statement on that first call. Say you're documenting the loss and will follow up.

Days 1–3: decide who represents you

The adjuster your insurance company sends works for the insurance company. In New York you can hire a licensed public adjuster who works for you instead — see our guide to public adjusters for how fees and contracts work.

If the loss is large, involves a business, or you're already getting pushback, talk to a public adjuster before the insurer's inspection and before any recorded statement or examination under oath.

Weeks 1–8: build the claim

Your claim is usually made up of the structure (building), contents (belongings, inventory, equipment), and additional living expenses or, for businesses, lost income. Each needs its own documentation: restoration and repair estimates, a contents inventory with photos, and receipts for every extra cost.

Keep damaged items until the insurer has documented them or approved disposal. If something must be thrown out for health reasons, photograph it and keep a sample.

The 60-day proof of loss rule

If your insurer sends a written request for a sworn proof of loss along with the form, New York law gives you 60 days to return it. Missing that deadline can be an absolute defense for the insurer, so put the date on your calendar the day the request arrives — see our proof of loss guide.

Before you settle

Don't accept a final payment until the full scope is known. Water travels under floors and behind walls, and smoke residue keeps spreading after the fire is out. Restoration moisture maps and a public adjuster's estimate help make sure the settlement covers everything.

Common questions

Should I call the restoration company or the insurance company first?

Both on the same day. Call a restoration company for emergency mitigation because your policy requires you to prevent further damage, and notify your insurer promptly with a short factual report. Don't wait days to report the loss.

Can I start cleanup before the insurance adjuster comes?

Yes — emergency steps to stop further damage are expected. Photograph everything first and keep damaged items, or samples, until the insurer documents them.

Do I have to give a recorded statement right away?

On the first call you can keep it to the basic facts and ask to schedule any recorded statement later. Many people talk to a public adjuster or attorney first.

Need help now? Call Jack at (646) 535-8762

Our crew serves Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island and Westchester.

Sources: NY DFS: adjusters, appraisers and umpires · NY Court of Appeals, Igbara Realty v. NYPIUA (proof of loss)

This article is general information about New York insurance claims, not legal advice, and not a substitute for instructions from the fire department, a licensed electrician, your insurer, a licensed public adjuster or an attorney. Policies differ — read yours, not a substitute for instructions from the fire department, a licensed electrician, or your insurance company. Restore Now NYC is operated by P National Group LLC, 1 Northside Piers, Brooklyn, NY 11249.

What to do right after a flood or water damage → What to do right after a house fire → What to do right after a flood or fire at your business → Insurance claim mistakes to avoid after water or fire damage → Public adjuster vs. insurance company adjuster: who works for you? → Why call a restoration company before the insurance adjuster arrives → The 60-day proof of loss rule in New York →

Call Jack nowFree quote