Safety first: Active fire, gas smell, or water near electrical panels? Call 911 first.
Call Jack · (646) 535-8762

Insurance claim guide

The 60-day proof of loss rule in New York

Updated · Restore Now NYC

Quick answer: In New York, when your insurer sends a written request for a sworn proof of loss together with the blank form, you have 60 days to send it back. New York courts have held that failing to file within those 60 days is an absolute defense for the insurer, unless the insurer waived the requirement — so treat that date as a hard deadline.

Need help now? Call Jack at (646) 535-8762

Our crew serves Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island and Westchester.

What a proof of loss is

A sworn proof of loss is a signed, often notarized statement of what was lost: the date and cause of loss, your interest in the property, other insurance, and the amount you're claiming for the building, contents and other coverages.

When the 60-day clock starts

The clock generally starts when you receive the insurer's written demand along with the proof of loss form. Write the date on the letter, put the deadline in your calendar, and keep proof of when you sent the completed form.

What happens if you miss it

New York's highest court held in Igbara Realty v. New York Property Insurance Underwriting Association that failing to file a proof of loss within 60 days of the insurer's written demand is an absolute defense to a lawsuit on the policy, absent waiver or estoppel. Courts continue to apply that rule.

How to protect yourself

Start documenting on day one so the numbers are ready: restoration reports and moisture logs, repair estimates, a contents inventory with photos, and receipts. If the full amount isn't known yet, many policyholders file on time with the best figures available and supplement later. A licensed public adjuster or attorney can prepare or review it.

Common questions

Does the 60 days start on the day of the loss?

Generally no. Under the New York rule it runs from the insurer's written request for a proof of loss, sent with the form.

What if I don't know the full amount yet?

File on time with your best documented figures and supplement later. Don't let the deadline pass while waiting for a perfect number.

Need help now? Call Jack at (646) 535-8762

Our crew serves Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island and Westchester.

Sources: NY Court of Appeals, Igbara Realty v. NYPIUA (1984)

This article is general information about New York insurance claims, not legal advice, and not a substitute for instructions from the fire department, a licensed electrician, your insurer, a licensed public adjuster or an attorney. Policies differ — read yours, not a substitute for instructions from the fire department, a licensed electrician, or your insurance company. Restore Now NYC is operated by P National Group LLC, 1 Northside Piers, Brooklyn, NY 11249.

What to do right after a flood or water damage → What to do right after a house fire → What to do right after a flood or fire at your business → Insurance claim mistakes to avoid after water or fire damage → How to handle a water or fire damage insurance claim in New York → Public adjuster vs. insurance company adjuster: who works for you? → Why call a restoration company before the insurance adjuster arrives →

Call Jack nowFree quote