Insurance claim guide
Public adjuster vs. insurance company adjuster: who works for you?
Updated · Restore Now NYC
Need help now? Call Jack at (646) 535-8762
Our crew serves Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island and Westchester.
Three kinds of adjusters
Company (staff) adjusters and independent adjusters both work for the insurance company. A public adjuster is the only kind that works for you. New York law says no adjuster may act on behalf of a policyholder unless licensed as a public adjuster.
What a public adjuster does
They read your policy for every coverage that applies, document the damage, prepare a detailed estimate and contents inventory, handle the paperwork and deadlines, meet the insurer's adjuster, and negotiate the settlement. Once you hire one, the insurer generally communicates with them about the claim.
What it costs in New York
The fee is a percentage of the money the insurer pays after you hire the adjuster. New York caps it at 12.5% of the recovery; for a supplemental claim the adjuster may charge up to 20% on that part, as long as the total fee stays at or under 12.5% of the full claim payment. The percentage is negotiable.
Your protections
The agreement must be in writing, and New York treats it like a door-to-door sale: you can cancel it within three business days. Licensed public adjusters may not solicit you between 6 p.m. and 8 a.m. They must disclose in writing any referral fee or ownership interest in a contractor working on your claim, and you're never required to use a vendor they recommend.
Check the license before you sign — DFS's "Who We Supervise" lookup lists licensed public adjusters.
When it's worth it — and when it isn't
A public adjuster tends to make the most sense for large or complex losses, fire claims with contents and smoke damage, commercial losses with business-interruption coverage, or claims that are already being underpaid or delayed. For a small, simple claim the fee may cost more than the adjuster adds.
Public adjuster plus restoration company
They do different jobs. The restoration company stops the damage and produces the technical record — photos, moisture readings, drying logs and scope of work. The public adjuster uses that record to make sure the claim covers everything. Getting both involved early gives you the strongest claim.
Some companies offer restoration and public adjusting together. New York allows that, but the public adjuster must disclose any ownership or financial interest in the restoration company in writing, must act in your best interest, and can't require you to use a particular contractor.
Common questions
Does the insurance company pay the public adjuster?
No. You pay the public adjuster, usually out of the claim payment, according to the written agreement you sign.
Can I cancel a public adjuster contract in New York?
Yes. New York gives you three business days to cancel a public adjuster's compensation agreement.
How do I check a public adjuster's license?
Use the New York Department of Financial Services' "Who We Supervise" lookup on the DFS website.
Need help now? Call Jack at (646) 535-8762
Our crew serves Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island and Westchester.
Sources: NY DFS: licensed public adjusters · 11 NYCRR 25.7 — public adjuster fee cap · 11 NYCRR 25.9 — right to cancel · 11 NYCRR 25.3 — solicitation hours · NY Insurance Law §2108
This article is general information about New York insurance claims, not legal advice, and not a substitute for instructions from the fire department, a licensed electrician, your insurer, a licensed public adjuster or an attorney. Policies differ — read yours, not a substitute for instructions from the fire department, a licensed electrician, or your insurance company. Restore Now NYC is operated by P National Group LLC, 1 Northside Piers, Brooklyn, NY 11249.
What to do right after a flood or water damage → What to do right after a house fire → What to do right after a flood or fire at your business → Insurance claim mistakes to avoid after water or fire damage → How to handle a water or fire damage insurance claim in New York → Why call a restoration company before the insurance adjuster arrives → The 60-day proof of loss rule in New York →